If you’re anything like me, college football is your first love, but the NFL still holds a special place in your heart. This summer, I was listening to a mailbag episode of my favorite NFL podcast, The Athletic Football Show, when a listener asked a question that got me thinking. He wanted to know which team-building approach the hosts preferred: the Chiefs model, built around a generational quarterback talent, or the Eagles model, which prioritizes defense (especially along the D-line), a strong run game, and surrounding a solid-but-not-elite QB with playmakers.
That question stuck with me. So I decided to apply the same framework to college football — specifically, to the 11 national champions of the College Football Playoff era (2014–2024). How many of those teams won primarily because of elite quarterback play? And how many leaned on physical defenses, power running games, and roster depth to win a title?
Before we dive in, I want to clarify how I’m defining each model.
With Kansas City, even in seasons where the defense has taken a leap or Mahomes hasn’t led the league in passing, he’s still the reason the Chiefs are perennial Super Bowl contenders. Having weapons like Travis Kelce — and early on, Tyreek Hill — helps, but Mahomes can elevate everyone around him, which defines their success.
Now compare that to Jalen Hurts and the Eagles. Hurts was excellent during the 2024 playoffs and nearly flawless in the Super Bowl, where he won MVP honors. But throughout the regular season, his numbers were great, not spectacular: 2,903 passing yards, 18 touchdowns, and 14 rushing scores. Outside of Philadelphia, he’s not often ranked among the NFL’s elite QBs (a recent survey of executives, coaches, and scouts ranked him ninth).
That’s not a knock on Hurts; it’s context. The foundation for the Eagles’ success isn’t built on a generational talent at the quarterback position. It’s built on dominant line play, defensive depth, and a run game that wears opponents down. And for this exercise, that’s an important distinction. Several of the national champions I grouped under the Eagles model had great quarterback play at times — but elite QB play wasn’t the driving force behind their title run.
Let me know how I did. And now, let’s rewind the clock to the very first year of the College Football Playoff…
2014 Ohio State – Eagles
The very first College Football Playoff champion fits the Eagles model almost by default. Ohio State lost its starting quarterback, Braxton Miller, to a season-ending shoulder injury in fall camp. In stepped J.T. Barrett, a redshirt freshman who thrived in Urban Meyer’s spread system — throwing for 34 touchdowns and nearly rushing for 1,000 yards before suffering a broken ankle in the regular-season finale against Michigan.
Enter the most famous third-string quarterback in college football history: Cardale Jones. Thrust into the spotlight, Jones dominated in his first start — a shocking 59-0 blowout of Wisconsin in the Big Ten Championship — then followed it up with efficient and clutch performances in the playoff. He didn’t need to be spectacular as the Buckeyes leaned on a bruising run game led by Ezekiel Elliott, who rushed for 476 yards and 6 touchdowns in two playoff games.
The defense? Good, not great — finishing 19th in total defense — but it showed up when it mattered. The Buckeyes forced four turnovers in the semifinal win over Alabama and held Oregon’s high-octane offense (which averaged 46.5 points per game) to just 20 points in the national title game.
Like the 2024 Eagles, the 2014 Buckeyes rode a deep, physical roster — anchored by trench play, a dominant run game, and timely defensive stops — to a national championship.
2015 Alabama – Eagles
The 2015 Alabama Crimson Tide might be the cleanest college football equivalent of the Eagles model. This team was built on three pillars: a dominant defense, a punishing ground game, and efficient, mistake-free quarterback play.
Jake Coker wasn’t a Heisman contender, but he managed the offense effectively all season — and saved his best for the national title game. Against Clemson, Coker threw for a season-high 335 yards, two touchdowns, and no interceptions, delivering in the biggest moment — just like Jalen Hurts did for the 2024 Eagles.
Of course, the soul of Bama’s offense was running back and Heisman winner Derrick Henry. Henry rushed for a school-record 2,219 yards, scored 28 touchdowns, and averaged nearly 148 yards per game. He was Alabama’s version of Saquon Barkley.
And when Henry wasn’t on the field, Bama’s defense suffocated opposing offenses. Led by future NFL stars Jonathan Allen and Minkah Fitzpatrick, the Crimson Tide finished first in rushing defense, third in both scoring and total defense, and led the nation with 52 sacks.
Like the Eagles, this Alabama squad dominated opponents with its trench play, physicality, and a roster filled with NFL-caliber talent. They didn’t need a superstar quarterback to win it all.
2016 Clemson – Chiefs
Dabo Swinney’s first national title was won the Chiefs way — on the back of a transcendent quarterback. Clemson doesn’t win it all without Deshaun Watson, a back-to-back Heisman finalist and one of the most dynamic QBs in college football over the last 20 years. In the regular season, Watson threw for over 3,600 yards and accounted for 38 total touchdowns, guiding one of the nation’s most explosive offenses.
The Tigers did have a strong defense — finishing 8th nationally in total defense — but this championship run was defined by Watson’s brilliance. After falling to Alabama in the 2015 title game, Clemson needed a superstar effort to take down the Crimson Tide in the rematch.
Watson delivered. Trailing late, he engineered an 88-yard drive in the final two minutes, capped by a game-winning touchdown pass to Hunter Renfrow with just one second left. He finished the game with 420 passing yards, four total touchdowns, zero turnovers, and earned Offensive MVP honors.
It was the kind of performance — and ending — that mirrored late-game heroics we’ve become used to seeing from Patrick Mahomes in the playoffs.
2017 Alabama – Eagles
How could a team led by Jalen Hurts not reflect the Eagles model? While the lasting image from Alabama’s 2017 national title run is true freshman Tua Tagovailoa coming off the bench to rally the Tide past Georgia in the second half of the championship game, the bigger story is the team’s foundation and how Hurts led them there.
Hurts started every regular-season game and guided one of the most balanced and efficient offenses in the country. Alabama averaged 37 points per game and rushed for over 250 yards per game. Hurts accounted for 36 total touchdowns (eight rushing) and threw just three interceptions all year — a model of ball security.
Defensively, this Alabama team was vintage Saban: physical, fast, and suffocating. The Tide allowed just 11.9 points per game and finished No. 1 in total defense.
Like the Eagles, this title was built on elite defense, a dominant rushing attack, and a mobile quarterback who didn’t need to be heroic every week — just efficient and reliable. Even though Tua delivered the final blow, it was Hurts and the team’s identity that got them there.
2018 Clemson – Chiefs
It’s hard to believe Trevor Lawrence didn’t start the 2018 season. The true freshman took over for Kelly Bryant in Week 5, and from that point forward, Clemson never looked back. The No. 1 overall recruit in the 2018 class, Lawrence is one of the rare examples of a top-ranked quarterback not only meeting expectations as a freshman, but exceeding them.
Lawrence finished the season with a Heisman-caliber stat line: 3,280 passing yards, 30 touchdowns, and only four interceptions. He led a Clemson offense that ranked fourth nationally in scoring and helped guide the Tigers to a perfect 15–0 season. While Clemson’s defense was elite — finishing first in scoring (13.1 points per game) — it was Lawrence’s performance in the national championship that defined this team’s identity.
Facing defending champion Alabama, Lawrence was unfazed. He threw for 347 yards and three touchdowns in a stunning 44–16 rout, earning Offensive MVP honors and cementing himself as the engineer of Clemson’s title run. He became the first true freshman quarterback since 1985 to start the majority of the season and win a national title.
Like Patrick Mahomes for the Chiefs, Lawrence didn’t just manage the moment; he elevated his team to an elite level and led Clemson to defeat the best program in the sport for the second time in three years.
2019 LSU – Chiefs
If there’s a perfect college football parallel to the Mahomes-era Chiefs, it’s the 2019 LSU Tigers.
The comparison starts, of course, with the quarterback. Joe Burrow delivered arguably the greatest season in college football history — throwing for 5,671 yards and a record-setting 60 touchdowns. He won the Heisman Trophy in a landslide, tossed 14 touchdown passes in just two playoff games, and earned Offensive MVP in the national championship.
Burrow’s season mirrors what Patrick Mahomes accomplished in 2022: over 5,000 passing yards, 41 touchdowns, and both NFL MVP and Super Bowl MVP honors. Like Mahomes, Burrow was the engine of a championship team built primarily on explosive offense and elite quarterback play.
Defensively, both teams had stars — LSU featured future pros like Derek Stingley Jr. and Patrick Queen, while the Chiefs had Chris Jones up front — but neither unit was dominant. The Chiefs finished 15th in both scoring and total defense in 2022. LSU was 32nd in scoring defense, making them one of only two national champions in the BCS/CFP era (along with 2010 Auburn) to win a title with a defense ranked 30th or worse.
And then there were the weapons. LSU’s offense boasted two of the NFL’s current elite: Ja’Marr Chase and Justin Jefferson, who each eclipsed 1,500 receiving yards and 18 touchdowns. For the Chiefs in 2019, it was Tyreek Hill and Travis Kelce putting up similarly devastating numbers as Mahomes’ go-to playmakers in their first Super Bowl run.
The formula was simple, and unstoppable: an elite quarterback, surrounded by elite weapons, backed by a good-enough defense. Just like the Chiefs, LSU didn’t need balance, just an offensive explosion.
2020 Alabama – Tossup
If there’s one team that’s tough to classify in this exercise, it’s the 2020 Alabama Crimson Tide. Defensively, this group — like all Saban-led units — was loaded with talent, including first-team All-Americans Patrick Surtain II and Christian Barmore, but it wasn’t dominant by Alabama standards. The Tide finished 13th in scoring defense and 19th in total defense — a strong, but not elite, performance.
Offensively, Alabama was a juggernaut. The backfield featured Najee Harris, who rushed for over 1,400 yards and 26 touchdowns. DeVonta Smith became the first wide receiver to win the Heisman in nearly three decades. Jaylen Waddle was a game-breaking threat when healthy. And all of that firepower operated behind a Joe Moore Award–winning offensive line.
This was the kind of offense that, in theory, only needed a steady hand at quarterback. But Mac Jones was much more than a game manager. A Heisman finalist himself, Jones threw for over 4,500 yards, 41 touchdowns to only four interceptions while completing a national-best 77.4% of his passes. His statistical dominance suggests a Chiefs-like model built around elite quarterback play.
So, how do you classify 2020 Alabama? On one hand, Jones and Smith put up video game numbers in a system that leaned heavily on their chemistry. On the other hand, the Tide’s success was equally driven by its power run game, trench dominance, and depth at every position — the same core pillars that carried the 2024 Eagles to a Super Bowl win.
2021 Georgia – Eagles
There may not be a more perfect example of the Eagles model than the 2021 Georgia Bulldogs.
Let’s start with the quarterback. Stetson Bennett, a former walk-on, began the season backing up 5-star transfer JT Daniels. But after injuries sidelined Daniels early, Bennett took over as the full-time starter by Week 4 and never gave the job back. While he wasn’t considered elite during the regular season, Bennett delivered when it mattered most — earning MVP honors in both the semifinals and the national championship game. His steady, clutch performance in the College Football Playoff mirrors the role Jalen Hurts played in the Eagles’ 2024 Super Bowl run: not the reason his team got there, but absolutely a key reason why they took home a ring.
Offensively, Georgia was efficient — ranking 9th in scoring — but the 2021 title was undeniably driven by a generational defense. The Bulldogs led the nation in scoring defense, ranked second in total defense, and third in rushing defense. Future Eagles Jordan Davis, Jalen Carter, Nolan Smith, and Nakobe Dean (starting defensive backs Kelee Ringo and Lewis Cine were also drafted by the Eagles) headlined a unit that routinely overwhelmed opponents at the line of scrimmage.
Just like the Eagles, 2021 Georgia won with physicality, depth, and defense — proving that a dominant front seven and a composed quarterback can still win it all.
2022 Georgia – Eagles
Stetson Bennett returned for a second senior season in 2022, using his COVID year to chase a repeat national championship — and both he and Georgia were rewarded. No longer just a former walk-on tasked with managing the offense, Bennett elevated his play to another level. He passed for 3,425 yards, accounted for 27 total touchdowns (seven rushing), completed 68% of his passes, and was named Offensive MVP of both the semifinal and national championship games for the second straight year. He also finished as a Heisman Trophy finalist.
With that kind of production, it’s fair to argue that 2022 Georgia could fit into the Chiefs model — or at least land in toss-up territory. But despite Bennett’s leap, this team still won the Georgia way: by dominating on the line of scrimmage.
While not quite as suffocating as the 2021 unit, Georgia still finished top five nationally in scoring defense, rushing defense, and total defense. Their defining performance came in early November in a No. 1 vs. No. 1 showdown (CFP vs. AP) against Tennessee. The Bulldogs held the nation’s top-scoring offense to just 13 points — and didn’t allow the Vols to cross midfield until the third quarter. A rainstorm may have helped, but Georgia’s defense left no doubt who controlled the game.
Bennett may have taken a star turn, but Georgia’s title defense was powered by the same formula as before: elite talent, trench dominance, and a defense that set the tone every Saturday. It still fits the Eagles mold.
2023 Michigan – Eagles
Another national champion, another team carried by a dominant defense. While quarterback J.J. McCarthy was a future first-round pick, Michigan’s offense didn’t rank among the top 20 nationally. The rushing attack finished just outside the top 50, and the Wolverines averaged under 400 total yards per game.
Still, McCarthy played his role exceptionally well. He completed 72.3% of his passes, threw just five interceptions, and helped the offense score 35.9 points per game — not explosive, but efficient and mistake-free. Like 2015 Alabama and 2021 Georgia, this was a team where an elite defense didn’t need fireworks from the offense, just ball control, timely scoring, and few self-inflicted wounds.
And Michigan’s defense was elite. The Wolverines finished first in scoring, passing, and total defense, and delivered their defining performance in the national title game. Facing a high-powered Washington offense led by another future first-round QB in Michael Penix Jr., Michigan held the Huskies to a season-low 13 points — a unit averaging 36 points per game heading into the matchup.
Michigan wasn’t flashy, but it was overwhelming, much like the Eagles.
2024 Ohio State – Eagles
It’s fitting that the most recent national champion was built in the mold of the 2024 Super Bowl Champion Philadelphia Eagles. Ohio State’s defense was dominant all season — finishing first in both scoring and total defense — with one poor performance in a 32–31 loss at Oregon (defense did its part in the 13-10 loss to Michigan). In the playoffs, the Buckeyes turned up the intensity, consistently controlling field position and forcing timely turnovers. Signature moments included holding Tennessee’s high-octane offense to just 256 yards in the opening round, avenging the Oregon loss with a decisive win in the quarterfinal, and Jack Sawyer’s scoop-and-score in the Cotton Bowl that stifled a late Texas rally. In the national title game, Ohio State built a 28–7 lead over Notre Dame and coasted to a 34–23 victory.
Offensively, the Buckeyes mirrored the Eagles’ run-first identity, anchored by a two-headed backfield of Quinshon Judkins and TreVeyon Henderson, who combined for over 2,000 yards and 24 touchdowns. Quarterback Will Howard completed more than 73% of his passes and delivered when it mattered, getting the ball to his playmakers — especially freshman sensation Jeremiah Smith. Smith caught two touchdowns in each of Ohio State’s first two playoff wins, missed much of the semifinal due to injury, then returned to form in the title game, hauling in another touchdown and a pivotal 56-yard reception on third-and-11 to help seal the win after Notre Dame had cut the lead to eight.
Like the Eagles, the Buckeyes won with depth, physicality, and timely execution. A national champion forged in the trenches, not built on a single superstar.
Final tally: Seven CFP champs built like the current iteration of the Philadelphia Eagles, three title winners won the Chiefs’ Way, and one toss-up.
By Jake Thigpen (@Jake_Thigpen)