By: Steve Smith
Week 1 of the college football season has come and gone, and while it would be a bit of a fool’s errand to rank Heisman hopefuls at this point of the season, it’s never too early to set the table with standout performers. As we progress through the season, we will highlight players who appear to be throwing their name into the Heisman hat. We will also plan to post Heisman power rankings at the quarter, halfway, and three-quarter points of the season, ultimately leading into a final prediction before the winner is announced in December.
There were plenty of noteworthy performances over the holiday weekend, and we’ll start by heading to Tallahassee, where Thomas Castellanos and the Florida State Seminoles pulled off the stunning upset over Alabama. While the box score doesn’t jump off the page, anyone who watched the game would tell you that Castellanos was in complete control of the contest. Whenever the Seminoles needed a play, their transfer QB answered the bell. FSU head coach Mike Norvell may have hit a grand slam by reuniting Castellanos and elite play-caller Gus Malzahn. We can’t give the trophy to Gus, but if Castellanos and company continue to play at this level, he could find himself making a leap from dark horse to Heisman favorite.
Another performance that was more “eye test” than statistical explosion was by LSU quarterback Garrett Nussmeier. It is clear that Nussmeier can make all of the throws and will be doing so on Sundays this time next season. He outperformed fellow Heisman hopeful Cade Klubnik while taking down Clemson, allowing LSU to stake a solo claim to the “Death Valley” title. Nussmeier looks poised to remain on this list all fall, as he pursues a Burrow-esque sweep of the Natty and the Heisman.
Rocco Becht and the Iowa State Cyclones followed up their big win in Ireland with a sound whipping of FCS South Dakota. While it wasn’t exactly a playoff-like matchup, Becht played well again and has six total touchdowns without throwing an interception so far in 2025. If he can keep the Cyclone train rolling, Becht could find himself making some waves in the race. He is as steady as it gets.
South Carolina quarterback LaNorris Sellers looked like the second coming of Cam Newton. That is, of course, hyperbole (kind of), but the size, speed, and athleticism of Sellers scream Heisman finalist. The Gamecocks look like another SEC force, and Sellers has the look of a superstar who can beat teams in several ways. There is serious helium for Sellers, and it might be a good time to get in now before the hype train completely leaves the station.
Arizona State wide receiver Jordyn Tyson had a field day at the expense of an overmatched Northern Arizona team with 12 receptions for 141 yards and two touchdowns. Tyson will continue to put up uber numbers for the defending Big12 champion Sun Devils, but may not even be the number one Heisman contender in his offensive huddle with Sam Leavitt calling signals for the potent ASU offense.
Other Quick Hitters:
-Oklahoma quarterback John Mateer had a brilliant Sooner debut with more than 400 total yards and four touchdowns.
–Gunner Stockton tallied four total scores and 73 rushing yards as Georgia dismantled Marshall.
–DJ Lagway was a methodical 15/18 for three scores as Florida cruised in their opener.
–Jordan Dwyer was electric for TCU with nine catches for 131 yards and a score as he helped welcome North Carolina coach Bill Belichick to the college ranks.